I spent weeks digging through actual market data — not theory, not back-of-napkin simulations — but real returns, real volatility, and real risk. And I found something NOBODY is talking about.
A portfolio that completely crushed the market in 2024…
…got absolutely wrecked in 2025.
And what I discovered might flip everything you thought you knew about diversification upside down. 🧠💥
Let’s break down what really happened.
📊 The Experiment
I analyzed nearly TWO years of real market data (Jan 2024 – Dec 14, 2025):
✔ No estimates
✔ No hypotheticals
✔ Only real-world performance
And I put three of the most widely debated portfolios head-to-head:
🥇 Portfolio 1 — The Minimalist (2-ETF)
-
70% VTI
-
30% BND
-
Expense ratio: 0.03%
→ Jack Bogle’s favourite.
🥈 Portfolio 2 — The Goldilocks (3-ETF)
-
60% VTI
-
20% VXUS
-
20% BND
-
Expense ratio: 0.04%
→ The “professional standard.”
🥉 Portfolio 3 — The Perfectionist (4-ETF)
-
50% VTI
-
15% VXUS
-
25% BND
-
10% AGG
-
Expense ratio: 0.045%
→ Maximum diversification… or so they say.
🔥 2024: The Year the US Stock Market Carried the World
US stocks dominated:
-
VTI: 22.99%
-
VO: 24.15%
-
VXUS (international): 2.84% 😬
-
Bonds: -1.8% to -1.9%
So how did the portfolios do?
🥉 4-ETF Portfolio — 11.28%
Adding AGG basically added no real diversification. Complexity ≠ Better.
🥈 3-ETF Portfolio — 14%
International allocation dragged it down.
🥇 2-ETF Portfolio — 15.55% ⭐
The simplest portfolio absolutely dominated 2024.
But wait…
Don’t celebrate yet. Because 2025 flipped the whole game.
🔄 2025: The Plot Twist Nobody Expected
Suddenly, international stocks EXPLODED.
-
VXUS: 28.52% 🤯
-
VTI: 16.16%
-
Bonds: ~3%
Total reversal.
And the portfolio rankings reversed too.
🥉 2-ETF Portfolio — 12.18%
The hero of 2024 became the struggler of 2025.
🥈 4-ETF Portfolio — 13.38%
Still too much bond drag.
🥇 3-ETF Portfolio — 15.98%
International exposure paid off BIG.
This is the power of global diversification.
💡 The Lesson Investors Keep Missing
If you only look at returns, you’re missing the real story:
👉 Risk-adjusted returns matter more than raw performance.
👉 You can’t predict which market will lead next year.
👉 International stocks outperform the US ~50% of the time.
The 2-ETF portfolio looked genius in 2024.
The 3-ETF portfolio looked genius in 2025.
Switching back and forth based on “last year’s winner” almost guarantees underperformance.
The only consistent winner?
Investors who pick a strategy and STICK WITH IT.
🧭 Which Portfolio Should YOU Pick?
🔥 Age < 40 (High risk tolerance)
-
80% VTI
-
20% BND
OR -
100% VTI
Long time horizon = volatility is your friend.
🔄 Age 40–60 (Moderate risk)
The 3-ETF portfolio is the sweet spot:
-
60% VTI
-
20% VXUS
-
20% BND
2025 proved this is the “set-it-and-forget-it” winner.
🧓 Age > 60 (Lower risk)
Use the 3-ETF approach but increase bonds:
-
40%–50% BND
🎯 The Real Winner
Not the 2-ETF.
Not the 3-ETF.
Not the 4-ETF.
The real winner is the investor who STAYS INVESTED.
If you chase performance, you lose.
If you stay consistent, you win over decades.
💬 Are you Team 2-ETF or Team 3-ETF?
Drop a comment! ⬇️
Hit LIKE if this saved you from a bad financial decision.
And SUBSCRIBE for more real data — not guessing.
🚀 Ready to Start Your ETF Portfolio?
If this breakdown opened your eyes and you’re ready to start investing in ETFs the smart way…
👉 I personally recommend using moomoo — one of the most powerful, beginner-friendly broker apps with low fees, advanced data, and global market access.
Start building your ETF portfolio today with moomoo:
👉 https://j.moomoo.com/0xFRE4
Grab the promo while it lasts and begin your investing journey the right way. 📈🔥
