Recently, a viewer DM’d me asking: “Should I invest in physical gold or a gold ETF?” Sounds simple, right? But it’s really like asking: “Should I buy KFC or KFC stock?” The answer depends entirely on your goals.
One gold bar in your hand solves one problem. Paper gold (like ETFs) solves another. Today, instead of giving you a straight answer, let’s dive into the pros and cons of each—and by the end, I’ll reveal my personal favorite strategy. Welcome to Finance Chat!
Step 1: Define Your Goal 🎯
Before debating which is better, ask yourself: Why do I want to invest in gold?
-
For peace of mind → Treat it like insurance.
-
For returns → You’ll end up trading constantly.
There’s also a third mindset, which is dangerous: people who buy gold hoping it will compound like a business but just hold onto it. Reality check: gold is a non-productive asset. It doesn’t pay dividends or grow your income. If wealth growth is your goal, stocks usually outperform gold.
A fascinating study from New York University shows that $100 invested in S&P 500 in 1928 would grow to $982,000 by 2024, but $100 in gold would only be $12,000.
Key takeaway:
-
Buy physical gold for safety.
-
Buy gold ETFs for speculation.
-
Don’t fall into the trap of holding gold long-term expecting it to compound like stocks.
Step 2: Physical Gold vs Gold ETFs – Pros & Cons ⚖️
What are they?
-
Physical Gold: Bars or coins you hold in your hand.
-
Gold ETFs: Funds that track gold prices. You can buy and sell like stocks without touching the metal.
Important: Owning a gold ETF doesn’t mean you own physical gold.
Costs 💸
-
Physical Gold:
-
Grades: 999 (investment) vs 916 (jewelry).
-
Buy price is usually above spot, sell below spot. Spread: 5–9%.
-
Extra: storage, insurance, and authenticity verification fees.
-
-
Gold ETFs:
-
Tight spreads, no storage hassle.
-
Costs: brokerage + small annual expense ratio.
-
Liquidity 💧
-
Physical gold depends on local dealers. Selling can be slow.
-
ETFs: instant buy/sell, fast execution, scalable from RM500 to RM5M.
Psychology & Peace of Mind 🧘♂️
-
Physical gold gives offline security. A bar today remains a bar in 2060. Perfect for those who sleep better knowing it’s tangible.
-
ETFs offer speed, precision, and automation. Great for investors focused on returns.
Quick Summary ✅
-
Insurance/peace of mind → Physical gold.
-
Trading/returns → Gold ETFs.
-
You can also combine: keep some physical gold for security, and trade ETFs for growth.
Bonus Tip: Grow Wealth While Saving on Taxes 💵
From 1 Oct – 23 Dec 2025, Versa is running a PRS Bonus Quest. PRS (Private Retirement Scheme) is like EPF but private, and you can get RM3,000 tax relief per year.
-
Sign up with Versa and use my referral code UAVR6K5X.
-
Make your first cash-in of minimum RM100.
-
You’ll get RM10 bonus plus extra 4.2% p.a. return in Versa Save until 31 Jan 2026 (pro-rated up to RM50,000).
Download Versa Now & Claim Your Bonus!
Physical gold helps you sleep better, but PRS and smart investing make your money work harder for you.
💡 Final Thought: Know your goal first, then choose wisely. Want security? Physical gold. Want growth? ETFs. Or mix both.
#InvestSmart #GoldInvesting #FinancialFreedom #VersaInvest #PRSBonus #WealthGrowth #MoneyTips
