Imagine this: over 30 years, you could lose $176,000 — not because the market crashed, not because of bad stock picks, but simply because you picked the wrong dividend ETF and paid hidden fees. Shocking, right? Millions of dividend investors are making this mistake right now.
Today, we’re diving into the ultimate comparison of US vs International Dividend ETFs, uncovering which ones truly make your money grow, which ones quietly destroy wealth, and how to optimize your portfolio for maximum income and growth.
The US Dividend ETF Champions
SCHD – The superstar for long-term dividend investors.
-
Tracks the Dow Jones US Dividend 100 with a quality-first approach.
-
Screens for cash flow, debt ratios, return on equity, and 5-year dividend growth.
-
Yield: 3.81% | Expense ratio: 0.06%
VM (Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF) – The broad diversification option.
-
580 holdings, Yield: 2.6%, but delivered 105.5% total returns over 10 years.
-
Capital appreciation + dividends = real wealth.
HDV – Quality-focused, using Morningstar’s economic moat ratings.
-
Yield: 3.48% | 10-year returns: 152.95%
-
Avoids chasing unsustainable payouts.
DVY – The "performance star"? Not so fast.
-
10-year returns: 178.71%, Expense ratio: 0.38%
-
On $100,000 invested over 30 years, those higher fees could cost you $176,000 compared to SCHD. Yes, fees compound against you.
SPYD – High yield alert: 4.48%.
-
Top S&P 500 dividend payers, equal weighting.
-
Sounds great? Beware of concentration risk and volatility that kills long-term compounding.
International Dividend ETFs – Higher Yield, Higher Complexity
VMI – Tracks 1,498 holdings across developed markets outside the US.
-
Yield: 4.21% | Expense ratio: 0.29%
-
Exposure to Europe, UK, Japan, Australia = diverse economic cycles.
SCHY – The international twin of SCHD.
-
Same quality methodology, 10-year dividend history required.
-
Yield: 3.51% | Expense ratio: 0.08%
-
Hidden gem for cost-conscious international exposure.
Expensive alternatives:
-
IDV: 4.5% yield, 0.5% fees
-
LVHI: 4.88% yield, 0.4% fees
-
GCW: 0.6% fees — long-term buy-and-hold becomes questionable.
Why International ETFs Yield More
-
European companies pay larger dividend percentages.
-
Mature markets return capital due to limited growth opportunities.
-
International ETFs trade at valuation discounts.
-
US tech growth outpaces defensive international markets right now.
Valuations Matter
-
US ETFs: P/E 15.5–18.7 (SCHD: 16.68, VYM: 18.71)
-
International ETFs: P/E 8.86–14.27 (VMI: 8.86, SCHY: 14.27)
-
Opportunity alert: International ETFs are often 50% cheaper than US counterparts.
Taxes – US ETFs Win in Tax Efficiency
-
SCHD: 99% qualified dividends → taxed at 0%, 15%, or 20%
-
International ETFs: 15–30% foreign withholding + ordinary income tax
-
Outcome: US ETFs can save $3,000+ per $100,000 invested annually
Currency Risk
-
Buying VMI or SCHY exposes you to euro, pound, yen, AUD fluctuations.
-
Long-term offset, short-term volatility — just something to watch.
Recommended ETF Allocations
Conservative income investors (55+):
-
70% SCHD + 30% SCHY → 3.7% yield, growing 8–10% annually, cost: 0.07%
Balanced growth-income investors (40–55):
-
50% VM, 30% SCHD, 20% SCHY → 3.2% yield, 9–10% CAGR, broad diversification
Growth-oriented investors (25–45):
-
60% VM, 20% HDV, 20% VMI → 2.8% yield, 10–11% total returns
High-income earners:
-
Taxable accounts: 100% SCHD
-
Retirement accounts: 50% SCHD + 50% VMI → capture international exposure without tax penalty
Key Takeaways
-
Keep fees under 0.1% for long-term holdings.
-
Use US ETFs in taxable accounts for tax efficiency.
-
Use SCHY for cost-effective international exposure.
✅ Avoid DVY (0.38% fees), GCU (0.6% fees), IDV & LVHI unless necessary.
✅ Follow these rules and you’ll outperform 95% of dividend investors over 30 years.
💡 Ready to start investing in dividend ETFs today? Don’t wait! Open your account with Moomoo and buy top-performing ETFs like SCHD or SCHY now: Invest with Moomoo
