The use of "crypto vaults" is on the rise as investors seek returns from lending digital assets. Total deposits have now surpassed US$10 billion, up from US$4 billion early last year.
However, this growth has raised concerns regarding lending risks, automated liquidations, and smart contract vulnerabilities—drawing the attention of regulators in the United States (US) and Europe.
Crypto Vaults Offer Returns of Up to 20%
Crypto vaults are decentralized finance (DeFi) platforms that allow investors to deposit crypto assets, which are then deployed into lending or investment strategies to generate returns.
According to data from Blockworks, the returns offered typically range from 3% to 10%, while higher-risk strategies can yield 20% or more.
Each vault is overseen by a strategy manager—known as a "curator"—who is responsible for selecting investment strategies, setting risk parameters, and monitoring how assets are utilized.
This role is analogous to that of a fund manager in the traditional financial system; however, transactions are executed via smart contracts, eliminating the need for conventional intermediaries.
Liquidation and Hacking Risks
While they offer the potential for higher returns, crypto vaults are exposed to liquidity risks and automated liquidations—triggered when the value of collateral declines or when loan conditions are no longer met.
Stressed market conditions can trigger the automatic sale of assets, which in turn intensifies price pressure and accelerates losses.
Risks are further amplified when a vault utilizes illiquid tokens or relies on collateral whose value is pegged to other crypto assets.
Additionally, flaws in smart contract code and cyberattacks can lead to the loss of funds.
TRM Labs estimates that US$972 million was stolen from DeFi platforms during the first half of this year. The hacking incident involving the Resolv protocol in March also demonstrated how pricing mechanisms that are not properly updated can prevent a vault from recognizing a genuine decline in the value of tokens used as collateral.
SEC and ESMA Examine Regulatory Requirements
The growing volume of funds held in crypto vaults has prompted regulators to scrutinize the level of investor protection and the responsibilities of those managing investment strategies.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is reportedly examining whether certain vaults may be subject to securities laws—particularly when the assets held or the investment strategies employed involve securities.
Meanwhile, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has proposed oversight for entities acting as intermediaries within decentralized financial services, aiming to mitigate operational risks, smart contract vulnerabilities, and concerns regarding consumer protection.
"Curators" who actively manage assets and adjust investment strategies could potentially be viewed as akin to traditional fund managers, thereby necessitating stricter compliance requirements.
